Picture a new GI client. She's a VP at a firm in Midtown, works 50+ hour weeks, and has school-age kids who each have their own dietary needs. Her galley kitchen is so small she can't open the fridge and the oven at the same time. (This is New York, after all.).
She skips a real breakfast most days, relying instead on coffee and the dried-out bagel her company provides. Lunch is takeout, eaten at her desk while she works, squeezed in between meetings.
Three nights a week there's dinner out: pizza with the kids, a work dinner, and an 8pm birthday dinner with her girlfriends at a buzzy restaurant. She's bloated, uncomfortable, and frustrated, because she's trying to eat all the "right" things. But life gets in the way.
You build her a thoughtful protocol. She tries to follow it
Then comes a work trip. A sick kid. A deadline.
She gives up because it feels impossible. At her follow-up, she apologizes, because she feels like she's failed you. (She hasn't.)
And you're left wondering if you failed the client. After all, we don't want our clients to be even more frustrated on top of not experiencing any symptom relief.
If you're a registered dietitian or a board-certified nutritionist practicing anywhere near the city, you've met this client. Probably this week.
How New York clients changed the way I practice
When I started specializing in GI cases in 2018, I thought I had a pretty good handle on gut health. After all, I did get my own IBS, SIBO, and GERD under control.
Spoiler: my New York clients had other plans.
From my early days seeing clients at my kitchen/office table to my telehealth practice today, most of my clients have lived in the New York metro area.
And New Yorkers are a special breed. Work stress, financial stress, health stress. Long commutes and overscheduled calendars. The same frenetic energy that makes NYC so exciting also makes for an overstimulated nervous system.
On paper, my protocols were solid: low-FODMAP, gluten-free and dairy-free, low-histamine, plus supplements to improve digestion and address documented nutrient deficiencies. All evidence-based.
In real life, my clients kept running into the same walls. And I started to wonder if the NYC lifestyle was contributing to the root causes of their digestive issues.
"Carrie," struggling with her third round of SIBO, felt better on a low-FODMAP diet but found it impossible to follow perfectly (meaning she could not follow it for more than one meal). So we identified just the FODMAPs that aggravated her symptoms. Reducing (not eliminating) only those brought the same relief.
"Laurel" was on a self-imposed gluten-free, dairy-free diet and still felt miserable. She was skipping breakfast, eating big low-protein salads for lunch, then overeating at 9pm. (A very common NYC pattern.) We added an easy, portable high-protein breakfast, like lactose-free yogurt with berries and pumpkin seeds (which also revealed that dairy wasn't the issue, just lactose). We swapped her salads for grain bowls with cooked veggies. Her oversized dinners got smaller, and within a few weeks her constipation and bloating improved.
Laurel taught me something I now see again and again: GI symptoms aren't always about food sensitivities or intolerances. Once we addressed the New York lifestyle, many of my clients could tolerate foods they had been sure were the problem.
When I made changes easier and more strategic, my clients could actually implement them, and their symptoms improved considerably. So I stopped asking "what's the best gut healing diet?" and started asking: what can this client actually implement that will also address a root cause? I call that approach strategic simplicity: protocols simple enough for a busy New Yorker to follow, and targeted enough to work.
My New York clients also taught me how to work with the complex clients I see today. The client who has seen five doctors and tried nutrition protocols that never fit her life. The one who doesn't just walk in the door with IBS and SIBO, but also MCAS, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, POTS, or an autoimmune condition, on top of a cardiometabolic condition.
These are the intake questions that help me spot those New York patterns early, before I build a single protocol. Try them with your next client.
Start with when she eats, not just what she eats
Ask: What do your meal patterns look like on a typical workday? And on a night you're eating out?
Most busy clients don't think of skipping meals as a problem. Some even see it as discipline. But skipping meals often leads to overeating later in the day, which can trigger pain, gas, and bloating. Remember Laurel? Her first quick win had nothing to do with eliminating a food. It was adding in a more balanced breakfast.
Take a closer look at the takeout desk salad
Ask about the "healthy" foods, too: raw vegetables, salads, smoothies, grain bowls, legumes.
A health-conscious diet can sometimes make GI symptoms worse. Clients with GI issues often struggle to digest raw or high-fiber foods, and the city's salad-for-lunch culture serves those up every single day. That takeout order she eats at her desk? Often a giant bowl of raw greens.
This question is especially valuable for the client who eats well and still feels miserable. She's doing everything she's been told is "healthy," and it can be a real relief for her to hear that her salad might be part of the problem.
Laurel did better with grain bowls and cooked veggies. For a busy client, the easiest way to make that kind of swap is to stop relying on takeout altogether. Replacing her desk lunch with Square Fare meals, customized to her needs, means the gentler, more satisfying option simply shows up. No cooking, no decisions between meetings.
Help your A-type client find room in her calendar to heal
Ask: Are you experiencing excess stress in your life, and how do you handle it?
Your type A client will probably laugh at this one. Back-to-back meetings, school drop-off, homework help, a phone that never stops. She honestly doesn't know where gut healing is supposed to fit.
Stress is among the top drivers of GI symptoms through the gut-brain axis. So before you add anything to her to-do list, ask yourself:
Where in this client's week is there actually room for her gut to heal?
The answer might be smaller than you think. Before adding anything new, look at how she eats. Simply slowing down to chew her food can help improve digestive function. It also helps activate the parasympathetic nervous system, the "rest and digest" state her overstimulated body rarely gets to visit.
Make a plan for the 8pm reservation
Ask: What foods make you feel worse?
Clients won't always know their triggers, and that's okay. Their answers still reveal patterns. Diarrhea after dairy, every time. A list that's mostly high-FODMAP foods. The client reports the experience. You recognize the pattern.
That pattern becomes her restaurant plan. Instead of avoiding everything, pick the one or two triggers that matter most and make those the only rules on a night out.
In New York, dinner out is how people celebrate, network, and see the people they love. Helping a client say yes again might be the most meaningful win of the whole protocol. Being able to enjoy food in a social setting is an important part of gut healing.
Of course, identifying and addressing root causes are important for long-term relief. And for New York clients, this lifestyle can be just as big a part of the root cause: the skipped breakfast, the desk lunch, the nervous system that never gets a break. Ask about it on every intake, and your protocols get simpler and more likely to work.
A protocol only works if it fits the life it's going into. Here, that life includes a tiny kitchen and an 8pm reservation.
Want to make sure you're asking the right intake questions? The questions above come from my free Root Cause Intake Checklist: the seven questions I ask every GI client before I build their protocol, with a short note on why each one matters.
Sara Kahn, MS, CNS, CDN, is a New York nutritionist who has specialized in complex GI cases since 2018. She sees clients through Belly Bliss Nutrition and offers a continuing education course for nutrition professionals through GI Nutrition Mastermind.